Email safety

Medicare’s Deadline Is December 7. The “Last Chance” Emails Are Fake.

Emilia, the blue Easy Mail robot, relaxes in a chair with tea while a phone frantically waves a countdown flag

The first two Medicare posts this fall covered the emails that arrive before enrollment and the five fakes that show up during it. This is the third act. It starts around now, builds through November, and peaks in the last week before December 7.

Quick version: Open Enrollment ends December 7. That is the only deadline. Medicare does not send countdown emails, “final notice” emails, or “your plan expires at midnight” emails. If you are happy with your plan, you do not have to do anything at all. If you are not, go to Medicare.gov yourself or call 1-800-MEDICARE.

The theme is urgency. Every email is a countdown.

What the deadline actually means

From Medicare.gov: Open Enrollment runs October 15 through December 7, and if you join or switch a plan, coverage starts January 1, as long as the plan gets your request by December 7.

Here is the part the scam emails leave out: if you do nothing, nothing happens. Your current plan continues into next year. There is no penalty for ignoring Open Enrollment. The deadline only matters if you want to change something.

And if you are in a Medicare Advantage plan and change your mind in January, there is a second window, January 1 through March 31, to switch again.

So there is no “last chance.” There is a date, and after it, the same coverage you had.

The emails you will see this month

“FINAL NOTICE: Your Medicare enrollment is incomplete.” Enrollment is not a thing that is “incomplete.” Either you asked to change plans or you did not. Nobody at Medicare is waiting on a missing form from you.

“Your plan expires December 7. Act now to avoid losing coverage.” Plans do not expire on December 7. December 7 is the last day to request a change for January. Coverage continues either way.

“You have 3 days left to claim your 2027 benefits.” Benefits are not claimed. They are yours. This email exists to make you tap.

“Your premium will increase unless you re-enroll today.” Real premium changes come from your plan by postal mail, in the Annual Notice of Change, which arrived in September. Anything by email with a same-day deadline is fake.

“Speak to a licensed Medicare agent before the deadline.” Some of these are real insurance agents. Some are not. Either way, Medicare itself does not send emails routing you to agents. If you want help, your state’s SHIP program provides free, unbiased counseling and does not sell plans.

Why November is the worst month

The scammers know three things. You have heard “December 7” on TV all fall. You are probably not sure whether you were supposed to do something. And you are busy with Thanksgiving. Uncertainty plus a deadline plus distraction is the recipe.

The phone adds one more ingredient. On a small screen, “FINAL NOTICE” in the subject line fills the whole preview. You feel the deadline before you see the sender.

What to do

  1. Decide now whether you want to change your plan. If the answer is no, you are done with Open Enrollment. Delete every Medicare-related email that arrives between now and December 7 without opening it.
  2. If the answer is yes, open your browser, type medicare.gov, and use the Plan Finder. Or call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227). Or call your SHIP counselor. None of those start from an email.
  3. Never tap a link in a Medicare email. Same rule as the last two posts. It has not changed and it will not.
  4. If you already tapped one, our guide I tapped the link. Now what? walks through exactly what to do.

How Easy Mail fits in

By November your inbox has six weeks of fake Medicare mail in it, across every address you own. Easy Mail puts Gmail, Yahoo, and Outlook in one inbox on your home screen and clears the promotional and junk pile with one tap, so when the real Annual Notice from your plan is sitting there, it is not buried under forty “FINAL NOTICE” emails.

Get Easy Mail Email Launcher on Google Play.

Download Easy Mail on Google Play

Frequently asked questions

If I miss December 7, do I lose my Medicare?

No. Your current coverage continues. December 7 is only the deadline to request a change for January 1.

I want to switch plans but I’m nervous about doing it online. Is there a person I can talk to?

Yes. 1-800-MEDICARE is staffed around the clock during Open Enrollment. Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) offers free, in-person or phone counseling and does not sell anything. Search “SHIP” plus your state name, or ask at your local senior center.

Is it a scam if the email says it’s from my own insurance company?

Not necessarily, but treat it the same way. Do not tap. Call the member services number on your insurance card and ask whether they sent it.

Sources: Medicare.gov: Joining a plan